"To Philosophize Is To Learn How To Die"

   In reading Critchley’s article, “To Philosophize Is To Learn How To Die,” I found many ideas that were extremely interesting to me and stood out to me. Critchley brings up a good point about fear followed by another about anxiety which are two feelings that the world has felt greatly throughout the past six months, so we are all no stranger to them. Through referring to Aristotle’s idea that, “Fear is our reaction to an actual threat in the world,” Critchley shows us that fear is caused by an actual threat, and typically when someone does not know what is to come from something going on, they will experience fear. Anxiety is more complicated than fear. Anxiety, defined by Critchley, is, “a state in which the particular facts of the world recede from view.” To me anxiety is that feeling of being “on-edge”; it is that uncontrollable feeling of worry along with intrusive thoughts and increased irritability and restlessness. Critchley states that there has been a fear of getting the virus, but behind this, people experience deep anxiety mainly towards the thought of ourselves dying or the thought of others dying.

Conversations about death and mortality, tend to be avoided at all costs. These conversation topics make people so uncomfortable that they instantly will turn away from them, and that is due to the lack of knowledge people have about death. To me, people experience death everyday. Plans get cancelled, food goes bad, the weather switches unexpectedly, we swat a fly in our kitchen, someone moves away, etc. These cancellations or minor changes could be considered the death of ideas or future plans. We don’t know what happens after our bodies die just like we don’t know what would’ve happened if the plans we made with our friends didn’t get cancelled. When you constantly are thinking about the negative occurrences of cancellations or deaths of future events in your life, you fall a slave to these negative, intrusive thoughts. Critchley shows a quote from Montaigne which says, “He who has learned to die has unlearned how to be a slave.” Those who fear death so much that they don’t like to talk about it are those who are slaves to it. Death is the one thing in our life that is entirely certain, and it cannot be changed. I have heard people say things about how we work so hard in life everyday just to die in the end, and I have always wondered why death is such a terrible thing to happen to them. They don’t know what comes of death nor do they know what happens after. We physically are gone, but are we gone mentally or emotionally? Our bodies are not what is powerful, but our minds are, and I do not believe that the mind ever dies. 

The pandemic has been a scary thing, but we as humans have learned to grow with it. We have made changes to our daily life. What we are doing this year is not at all what we would have expected to do, but we’re doing it. Who knows where we will be next year? We have all now experienced what it is like to have genuinely nothing to do except have responsibility over what we plan to do with our days. If you look at everything in life as a chance to grow, you will grow, but if you look at everything as something unknown and scary, you will experience anxiety and great fears. Some people believe happiness and freedom are masked by stress, anxiety, and discomfort, but these people are those who do not look at stress or discomfort as chances to grow instead they look at them as huge inconveniences.  Critchley’s article opened my eyes to many things that were right in front of me, and I agree with his thoughts on anxiety, fear, death, and freedom. 


Comments

  1. Hi Catherine!

    I think this is a very interesting take on the article! And I especially enjoyed the second paragraph where you put forth the idea that death takes place in everyday life, not in just the "extreme sense" but also in ways that may be overlooked as insignificant. The "death of ideas" was definitely something interesting to think about. I also enjoyed your emphasis on intrusive thoughts as part of anxiety, which is an aspect that you don't typically hear about in the discussion of anxiety.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Catherine

    I'm glad you brought up that during this pandemic we have dealt with fear and anxiety simultaneously, whereas I feel as though Critchley thinks we've only really dealt with generalized anxiety. I appreciate your perspective on death and the applications of the term that can represent the end to things other than physical death. It seems that if people were to change their perspective to not see death as so abrupt and intrusive, we would be able to not worry about it so much. Your optimism is very contagious!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Catherine,
    Your perspective on death and the topic in general was so interesting, I never thought of it that way! Our plans are cancelled every day, so if we focus on the negative we will never be happy, or at least not live in fear. I really was captivated reading your blog post, the ideas are so original and almost inspiring. And I also agree with you, we can't be so upset about death because it is unavoidable. Thank you for this blog post and I look forward to reading your work in the future!
    Rebecca

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Catherine,

    I'd like to ask you about a couple sentences in your thoughtful post. You write: "Our bodies are not what is powerful, but our minds are, and I do not believe that the mind ever dies." I'm curious to hear more about what you mean by these statements and what your reasons are in support of them. Why are our bodies not powerful? Why do you think that the mind never dies? How does the mind survive the death of the body? I'd love to read your thoughts expanding on these ideas. These would also be good questions to take up again in the context of the next reading (Perry 1978)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dr. Nora,

      When I say that our mind is more powerful that the human body and that it never dies, I am stating a quite strong belief of mine. I have always felt that the human body is a temporary place for our mind to grow and mature. The body is awesome since we have these five senses; we get to experience such physical beauties everyday with it, but our body can get hurt, bruised and battered, diseased, and eventually give out and die. I don't think our mind is the same; I believe every single day the mind gets stronger and stronger, and when it is strong enough, stronger than the body that is, the body will die and the mind will go on to experience a different and eternal life. This is, of course, just a belief of mine which could just be a reassurance to myself that death of the body isn't the end of the mind and soul, and I definitely will be able to go more in depth with the next blog post and the next reading has some points that have quite strong correlation with mine.

      Delete

Post a Comment